What do these two athletes have in common? They were both dismissed from their respective teams due to honor code violations at BYU. The difference? Harvey Unga's dismissal happened in the off-season, while Brandon Davies was dismissed two games before the end of the regular season while the BYU basketball team was at the height of it's success.
In both cases, I was upset and disappointed...upset because the two teams lost star players. Disappointed because of devastating effects on the teams, but also because of the decisions that were made.
Last night, BYU played the first game without Brandon Davies, and he was definitely missed. Personally, I missed him in terms of the score (which was dismal, to say the least), and he was a lot of fun to watch and had a ton of talent. I also missed his part of the starting line up introductions. I love the pre-game intro when the players dance in a circle with Davies at the center. It makes for an exciting beginning to the games.
I am, however, very impressed at the positive attention BYU has received because of the whole situation. BYU is known for its high standards and honor code. Yes, the honor code is strict and requires a lot of the students, but every student that applies to BYU is aware of and agrees to the conduct and lifestyle required. Would it have been easier to have just hidden everything until after the NCAA tournament? Of course. Would anyone have really known? Probably not. But that is not how the school and the athletic program work. To dismiss a starting player, one who is high on the list of favorites, so close to the tournament says a lot. BYU is more willing to abide by standards than to perform well in sports.
CBS on the BYU Honor Code: BYU Honor Code: Was Brandon Davies unchaste, untrue, or worse? (please note the direct link to the Honor Code...I wonder how many hits it has had in the last 24 hours)
ESPN.com, Pat Forde: BYU Puts Principle over Performance
ESPN Insider Chris Broussard calls the honor code "refreshing." And Skip Bayless gives it respect.
And of course, his teammates stand by him... From People: Cougars teammate Jimmer Fredette says Davies "told us everything. He told us he was sorry and that he let us down. We just held our heads high and told him it was okay, that it is life, and you make mistakes, and you just got to play through it."
I will stand by BYU and the Honor Code. I also respect the decision that was made. I terribly miss Brandon Davies, but I respect him for the courage this must take. He's a great basketball player and hopefully, we will see in again in the future.




all, but last night they were awesome. I loved the blocks and the steals. Plus, they had some great offensive plays. Even though Jimmer scored about 60% of the points, the whole team played great!